Stephanie Briggs - Handmade Knitting My Way Through Chronic Pain

Knitting by hand, owned by three cats and a manbeast

  • Home
  • Shop
  • Blog
  • Prices
  • Contact
  • Love and Hugs

Books into Film: “The Other Boleyn Girl” and “Atonement”

16th January 2012 By stephanie

Lights...camera...turn the page!

Watching The Other Boleyn Girl while tying product tags onto Shivanaut scarves. I have the book by Philippa Gregory, but couldn’t get into it. From what I have read of the book, it’s “supposed” to be good (but it rankles me that she rewrites history and takes far too long to say things that could be written much more succinctly when they require it).

Ordinarily, I really enjoy big, meaty historical novels of subjects I like (for example, The Bronze Horseman* trilogy by Paullina Simons). But they watered down The Other Boleyn Girl so much from the book that I can’t keep track of everything in the book.

On the flip side, I’m really enjoying reading Atonement after having watched the film, and I’m not disappointed in the least by comparing McEwan’s book to film. A big part of me thinks that, had it been the case that the movie had come before the book, I could have done a much better job of writing the novel for The Other Boleyn Girl myself, and not just a dime-store movie novelization, either!

*There is currently a movie of  The Bronze Horseman in pre-production as of 2012. Given the huge scope of the novel, tither it will be fantastic, or it will be terrible. 

Filed Under: Play Tagged With: books, books into film, films, reading

You can edit the cell to style it and display other fields. Learn more about the Visual Editor Cell for Text, Images, HTML.

About stephanie

Copyright © 2025 ·Dynamik-Gen · Genesis Framework by StudioPress · WordPress · Log in